欢乐飞艇计划软件

所在位置: 工伤赔偿法律网 > 工伤程序 > 工伤认定 > 正文
职工下班后去母亲家吃饭,在返回自己家途中发生交通事故身亡,不属于工伤
作者:王睿卿 来源:上海法治报 发布时间:18-06-14 15:04:00 浏览量:

前言

ERZI“XIABANTUZHONG”CHEHUOSHENWANG,RENSHEJUQUEZUOCHUBUFUHERENDINGGONGSHANGTIAOJIANDEJUEDING。MUQINBUFUJUEDINGSHU,JIANGRENSHEJUGAOSHANGFAYUAN,YISHENBAISU,YOUTIQISHANGSU。RANER,ZUIHOUHAISHIMEINENGDAYINGGUANSI。RENSHEJUDEJUEDINGSHIJIYUZENYANGDERENDING?FAYUANZHICHIRENSHEJURENDINGDEYIJUYOUSHISHENME?


案情简介

ERZICHEHUOSHENWANGWEIHUOGONGSHANGRENDING,MUQINZHUANGGAORENSHEJUYISHENBAISU

NIMOUDEMUQINZENMEYEMEIXIANGDAO,NEISHITAHENIMOU“ZUIHOUDEWANCAN”。

2017年3月16日16时37分,倪某下班,17时45分左右回到母亲家,吃完晚饭后,骑电动自行车返回自己住处,19时55分途经玉田支路进玉田路北约60米处时,发生交通事故,连人带车倒地,遂送至医院,至医院已死亡。上海市公安局虹口分局交通警察支队出具道路交通事故认定书,认定倪某承担同等事故责任

2017NIAN4YUE11RI,MOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSIXIANGHONGKOURENSHEJUTICHUGONGSHANGRENDINGSHENQING,YINTIJIAOCAILIAOBUWANZHENG,RENSHEJUYAOQIUMOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSIBUCHONGTIJIAONIMOUYUYONGGONGDANWEICUNZAILAODONGGUANXIDEZHENGMINGCAILIAO。MOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSIYUTONGYUE28RIJIANGBUZHENGSHENQINGCAILIAOTIJIAORENSHEJU,RENSHEJUYU2017NIAN5YUE9RISHOULIMOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSITICHUDEGONGSHANGRENDINGSHENQING,BINGXIANGNIMOUMUQINYUMOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSISONGDASHOULIJUEDINGSHU。

虹口人社局经调查,认定倪某受到的事故伤害,不符合 《工伤保险条例》、 《上海市工伤保险实施办法》 第14条和第14条规定的认定工伤或者视同工伤的情形,遂于同年7月5日作出不予认定工伤决定,认定倪某受到的事故伤害,不符合 《工伤保险条例》、 《上海市工伤保险实施办法》 第14条、第15条规定的认定工伤或者视同工伤的情形,决定不予认定或者视同工伤,并将不予认定工伤决定送达倪某母亲和某物流公司上海分公司。倪某母亲收到决定书后不服,诉至法院。

FAYUANRENWEI,GENJU 《GONGSHANGBAOXIANTIAOLI》 DI5TIAODIERKUANZHIGUIDING,HONGKOURENSHEJUJUYOUZUOCHUBEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDINGDEFADINGZHIQUAN。QIZAISHOUDAOMOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSIDEGONGSHANGRENDINGSHENQINGHOU,JINGDIAOCHAHESHI,YUFADINGQIXIANNEIZUOCHUBEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDING,CHENGXUHEFA。


本案的争议焦点为倪某是否在下班途中发生交通事故,被诉不予认定工伤决定是否合法。

GENJU 《GONGSHANGBAOXIANTIAOLI》 DI14TIAODI(LIU)XIANGZHIGUIDING,ZHIGONGZAISHANGXIABANTUZHONG,SHOUDAOFEIBENRENZHUYAOZERENDEJIAOTONGSHIGUSHANGHAIDE,YINGDANGRENDINGWEIGONGSHANG。SHIFADANGRI,SHIGUFASHENGSHIJIANJULIXIABANYIYOU2XIAOSHI,QIEZAINIMOUXIABANHOUZHINIMOUMUQINCHUYONGWANCANHOUHUIJIATUZHONG,GUDANGRINIMOUXIABANHOUZHINIMOUMUQINCHUSHI,XIABANLUTUYIJINGJIESHU。SHEANJIAOTONGSHIGUBINGFEIFASHENGZAINIMOUXIABANTUZHONG,BUFUHERENDINGGONGSHANGHUOZHESHITONGGONGSHANGDETIAOJIAN,BEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDING,RENDINGSHISHIQINGCHU,SHIYONGFALVZHENGQUE。YINCI,NIMOUMUQINDESUSONGQINGQIUQUEFASHISHIGENJUHEFALVYIJU,FAYUANBUYUZHICHI。JUCI,YISHENFAYUANPANJUEBOHUINIMOUMUQINDESUSONGQINGQIU。YISHENPANJUEHOU,NIMOUMUQINBUFU,TIQISHANGSU。

NIMOUMUQINCHENG:GENJU 《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUSHENLIGONGSHANGBAOXIANXINGZHENGANJIANRUOGANWENTIDEGUIDING》 DI6TIAODI(ER)XIANGDUISHEBAOBUMENRENDINGDE“SHANGXIABANTUZHONGDE”,BAOKUOZAIHELISHIJIANNEIWANGFANYUGONGZUODIYUFUMU、ZINVJUZHUDIDEHELILUXIAN。NIMOUYUXIABANHOULAIMUQINJIA,RANHOUZAIHUIZIJIJIA,FUHEHELILUXIAN、HELISHIJIANZHIGUIDING,YINGYURENDINGWEIGONGSHANG。BEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDING,RENDINGSHISHIBUQING,SHIYONGFALVCUOWU,GUQINGQIUFAYUANCHEXIAOYUANSHENPANJUE,YIFAZHICHISHANGSURENDEYISHENSUSONGQINGQIU。

欢乐飞艇计划软件 HONGKOURENSHEJUCHENG:BEISHANGSURENJUYOUGONGSHANGRENDINGDEFADINGZHIQUAN,QIZUOCHU 《BUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDINGSHU》 CHENGXUFUHEFALVGUIDING,SUOYIJUDESHISHIQINGCHU、ZHENGJUQUEZAO,SUOSHIYONGDEFALVYIJUZHENGQUE、XINGWEISHIDANG。PANJUERENDINGSHISHIQINGCHU,SHIYONGFALVZHENGQUE,CHENGXUHEFA,QINGQIUBOHUISHANGSU,WEICHIYUANSHEN。


二审法院进一步解释,超出下班合理时间认知

欢乐飞艇计划软件 ERSHENFAYUANSHENLIHOURENWEI:BENANDEZHENGYIJIAODIANWEINIMOUFASHENGJIAOTONGSHIGUSHIFOUSHUYU“SHANGXIABANTUZHONG”,BEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDINGSHIFOUHEFA。

BEISHANGSURENHONGKOURENSHEJUZAISHOULIYUANSHENDISANRENMOUWULIUGONGSISHANGHAIFENGONGSIXIANGQITICHUDEGONGSHANGRENDINGSHENQINGHOU,JINGDIAOCHA,RENWEINIMOUSUOFASHENGDEJIAOTONGSHIGUBINGFEIZAIXIABANTUZHONG,GURENDINGNIMOUSHOUDAODESHIGUSHANGHAI,BUFUHE 《GONGSHANGBAOXIANTIAOLI》、 《SHANGHAISHIGONGSHANGBAOXIANSHISHIBANFA》 DI14TIAOHEDI15TIAOGUIDINGDERENDINGGONGSHANGHUOZHESHITONGGONGSHANGDEQINGXING,SUIZUOCHULEBEISUBUYURENDINGGONGSHANGJUEDING。SHANGSURENRENWEINIMOUZAIXIABANHOUQUMUQINJIACHIWANWANFANHUIJIATUZHONGFASHENGJIAOTONGSHIGU,SHUYUXIABANTUZHONG,YEFUHEHELILUXIAN、HELISHIJIANDEYAOQIU,GUYINGRENDINGGONGSHANG。DUIYUSHANGSURENZHIZINIMOUZAIXIABANHOUXIANQUMUQINCHUCHIFANZAIHUIZIJIJUZHUDIDEQINGKUANGSHIFOUSHUYUSHANGXIABANTUZHONG,FAYUANRENWEI,CONGGONGZUODIWANGFANJUZHUDIDELUXIANYINGRENWEISHISHANGXIABANTUZHONG,SUOYIBUKEFOURENNIMOUSHIZAIXIABANTUZHONGFASHENGDEJIAOTONGSHIGU。DANYAOFUHE 《GONGSHANGBAOXIANTIAOLI》、 《SHANGHAISHIGONGSHANGBAOXIANSHISHIBANFA》 DI14TIAOGUIDINGDERENDINGGONGSHANGQINGXINGDE“SHANGXIABANTUZHONG”HAIYAOFUHE 《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUSHENLIGONGSHANGBAOXIANXINGZHENGANJIANRUOGANWENTIDEGUIDING》 XIANGGUANQINGXING,YEJIUSHIWANGFANGONGZUODIHEJUZHUDIDEHELILUXIANHEHELISHIJIAN;YIJICONGSHISHUYURICHANGSHENGHUOSUOXUYAODEHUODONG,QIEZAIHELISHIJIANHEHELILUXIANDESHANGXIABANTUZHONG。

本案中倪某在下班后回自己居住地途中顺路去母亲处探望属日常生活所需要的活动也属正常,故符合上下班合理路线的要求;对于上下班合理时间的认定除了在合理路线上的往返时间外,还包括一些从事属于日常生活所需或顺便合乎情理的短暂停留而使用的时间,一般都是从事顺带或花费时间较短暂的生活所需活动。但倪某下班后至母亲处停留吃饭长达两小时,显然超出了正常下班的合理时间的认知欢乐飞艇计划软件,不符合上下班合理时间的要求,故不能认定为“上下班途中”。因此,被上诉人虹口人社局认为倪某发生的交通事故伤害并非在“上下班途中”,不符合认定工伤或者视同工伤的条件,作出被诉不予认定工伤决定,认定事实清楚,适用法律正确。综上,法院作出终审判决:驳回上诉,维持原判。


相关法条

《ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOXINGZHENGSUSONGFA》

DI86TIAO RENMINFAYUANDUISHANGSUANJIAN,YINGDANGZUCHENGHEYITING,KAITINGSHENLI。JINGGUOYUEJUAN、DIAOCHAHEXUNWENDANGSHIREN,DUIMEIYOUTICHUXINDESHISHI、ZHENGJUHUOZHELIYOU,HEYITINGRENWEIBUXUYAOKAITINGSHENLIDE,YEKEYIBUKAITINGSHENLI。

欢乐飞艇计划软件 DI89TIAO RENMINFAYUANSHENLISHANGSUANJIAN,ANZHAOXIALIEQINGXING,FENBIECHULI:

(YI)YUANPANJUE、CAIDINGRENDINGSHISHIQINGCHU,SHIYONGFALV、FAGUIZHENGQUEDE,PANJUEHUOZHECAIDINGBOHUISHANGSU,WEICHIYUANPANJUE、CAIDING。




本文地址:http://mattamar.com/rending/2018-6/8425.html
上一篇:下班后与同事一起吃烧烤,饭后回家时发生交通事故身亡,是否属于工伤?
下一篇:员工在单位外派期间发病,抢救无效后死亡,是否属于工伤?